
An employee hands you a new Form W-4. You’re entering it into payroll when you notice they checked “Exempt from withholding.”
And your first thought might be:
Wait… can they really do that?
Maybe they’re a full-time employee. Maybe they make a pretty good salary. Maybe you’re looking at that W-4 thinking there is absolutely no way this person should be exempt from federal income tax.
So, what are you supposed to do?
The answer is actually pretty simple: In most cases, you process the W-4 the way the employee completed it.
Whether the employee actually qualifies to claim exempt is generally between the employee and the IRS.
What Does “Exempt” Mean?
When an employee claims exempt on Form W-4, they are telling you that they meet the IRS requirements to have no federal income tax withheld from their paycheck.
Generally, to qualify, the employee must have:
- Had no federal income tax liability in the previous year, and
- Expect to have no federal income tax liability in the current year.
The employee is certifying that they meet those requirements when they complete their W-4.
As the employer, you are not responsible for reviewing their income, deductions, spouse’s income or overall tax situation to determine whether they really qualify.
That responsibility belongs to the employee.
Does That Mean No Taxes Come Out of Their Check?
No—and this is an important distinction.
Claiming exempt on Form W-4 generally stops federal income tax withholding only.
It does not automatically stop:
Social Security tax
Medicare tax
State or local taxes, when applicable
So, if an employee claims exempt, don’t simply turn off every tax in your payroll system. You’re changing their federal income tax withholding based on the W-4 they submitted.
State withholding is a separate issue and should be handled according to the rules and withholding forms for the state where the employee works and/or lives.
But What If I KNOW They Shouldn’t Be Exempt?
This is probably the question we hear most often.
Maybe the employee earns $75,000 a year and checks exempt.
You look at the form and think:
There is no way.
But here’s the important part: It’s not the employer’s job to make that call.
You don’t want to become the employee’s tax advisor.
Instead of telling an employee, “You can’t claim exempt,” you can explain what their selection means:
“By claiming exempt on Form W-4, you are certifying that you meet the IRS requirements for exemption from federal income tax withholding. We will process your withholding based on the W-4 you submitted.”
Then let the employee decide whether they want to change their form.
If they’re unsure whether they qualify, they should consult their tax professional or review the IRS instructions for Form W-4.
Don’t Forget: Exempt Status Expires
This is the part that can easily get missed.
An employee’s exempt status doesn’t just continue year after year.
Employees who want to remain exempt must generally submit a new Form W-4 each year by the IRS deadline, which is typically in mid-February.
If they don’t submit a new W-4 claiming exempt by the deadline, the employer must begin withholding federal income tax according to IRS requirements.
Payroll Partners Tip: At the beginning of each year, run a list of employees currently coded as exempt from federal income tax withholding. That gives you time to remind them that a new W-4 will be needed if they intend to continue claiming exempt.
What About an IRS Lock-In Letter?
There is one situation where the rules change.
If the IRS determines that an employee isn’t having enough federal income tax withheld, it may send the employer a lock-in letter.
A lock-in letter tells the employer how to calculate that employee’s federal income tax withholding.
Once you receive one, you must follow the IRS instructions. The employee generally can’t override the IRS-required withholding simply by handing you another W-4 claiming exempt.
If you receive a lock-in letter and aren’t sure what to do with it, don’t stick it in the employee’s file and hope for the best. Make sure it gets to the person responsible for processing your payroll.
So, What’s the Employer’s Responsibility?
When an employee gives you a properly completed W-4 claiming exempt, your job is to process the form—not determine whether the employee made the right tax decision.
Make the appropriate change to federal income tax withholding. Continue withholding Social Security and Medicare when applicable. Handle state withholding separately. Keep the W-4 with your payroll records. And remember to address exempt employees again when the annual renewal deadline rolls around.
And perhaps most importantly:
Don’t give tax advice.
You can explain what the employee’s W-4 selection does. You can explain how it will affect their paycheck. But whether they should claim exempt is a conversation for the employee and their tax professional.
We’re Here to Help
Payroll withholding can get complicated quickly—especially when employees start asking questions about W-4s, exemptions, multiple jobs, state withholding and everything else that can affect their paycheck.
That’s where Payroll Partners comes in.
We help our clients navigate the payroll side of these situations so you can stay focused on running your business.
Have a payroll question? Give Payroll Partners a call at (817) 226-8111. We’re always happy to help.
This information is provided with the understanding that Payroll Partners is not rendering legal, human resources, or other professional advice or service. Professional advice on specific issues should be sought from a lawyer, HR consultant or other professional.
